Redshirting: Holding Them Back To Get Them Ahead

photo credit: Pinterest

It is called “redshirting.” Perhaps you have heard of it.

“Redshirting for young children refers to the practice of postponing entrance into kindergarten of age-eligible children in order to allow extra time for socioemotional, intellectual, or physical growth. This occurs most frequently where children’s birthdays are so close to the cut-off dates that they are very likely to be among the youngest in their kindergarten class.”  (Wikipedia)

I discussed redshirting on Global TV this morning,

In simpler terms, ‘redshirting kindergarten’ is holding you child back one extra year before sending them to kindergarten. Instead of entering kindergarten as a 5 year old, if your child is on the cusp of the grade cutoff, that is, one of the youngest children in the grade, you would hold him or her back one year, and he or she would enter kindergarten as a larger, more developed, 6 year old.

photo credit: Pinterest

THE ADVANTAGE

The debate is an old one. But there is much talk lately around the redshirting debate. Parents are holding their kids back at record numbers, often to give their child a competitive advantage over their peers. It’s the slight competitive edge that they get as the oldest child in the grade vs. being the youngest in their grade, when pitted against their classmates.  They would be among the oldest and biggest in their classrooms… and on the sports fields.

THE THEORY

The theory goes back to 2008, the year of The Outliers. Malcolm Gladwell, famous for his work in this arena, and author of one of my favorite books, The Outliers, discussed the cold hard facts a couple of years ago on a 60 Minutes segment. He explained, for example, a very significant number of NHL hockey players are born in January, February and March- the closest to the January 1st NHL cutoff date, and therefore the oldest in their hockey year. He claims there is no coincidence… the older kids are bigger, faster, better and more physically and emotionally developed. Their age and size give them an advantage over the other players, which then slots them more frequently in the AAA teams. They then receive more ice time, better training, better coaching, and they are groomed at an overall far superior level than their younger peers. Gladwell claims this difference makes all the difference, and this advantage follows them year after year, even in academics. It is quite striking to see the stats on paper. Wayne Gretzky, and most hockey greats, are born in the 1st quarter of the year. Makes ya wonder.

To further explain my point, you can the CSB segment from 2012. The studies are astounding.  http://www.cbsnews.com/news/redshirting-holding-kids-back-from-kindergarten-04-03-2012/

You see, I have a child who is relevant to the discussion. Born right at the cutoff, the youngest in the grade, and a boy, to boot.  As he entered preschool at three, then preschool again at four, then kindergarten at five, my husband and I asked the professionals the same question every year, “Do we hold him back? Is he ready?” We had no interest in giving him a competitive advantage over his peers, we wanted to make sure he could keep up socially, emotionally and academically. They gave us the same answer every year, “While perhaps he is a little less socially mature than his peers at the beginning of the school year, he is one of our brightest students in the class, so we feel if you hold him back, you will be doing him a great disservice academically. He will be bored and unchallenged.” And so we listened.

Did we make the right decision? Who knows? Had we held him back, would he have been extra confident? Maybe. Would he have excelled even more at sports being the oldest? Perhaps. Would he have been smarter in school? Doubtful. Would he have had a better advantage in LIFE? We’ll never know. What we do know, is he’s thriving social, academically and otherwise, and we have never looked back. But parents are doing whatever it takes to make sure their kids DO have that life advantage. And believe me, I do get it.

THE WORRY
 
Some parents and experts worry about the academic and social impact on kids who enter school on time and in their correct school year, but end up being surrounded by so many younger, redshirted peers. Another concern is about the challenge teachers may face while trying to streamline a curriculum when there’s such a wide age range in the class. This trend which has started to catch on in Canada (especially Western Canada), is still very much an “American” thing—this notion that life is about dominating your competition from the earliest possible age.” (CanadianFamily.ca).
 
SO WHAT’S THE SCIENCE TELLING US?
 
In a nutshell, there’s a huge benefit when you’re younger, but that shrinks to something a little more negligible in high school.
There are some studies which told us that older children were more likely to take on leadership roles (captain of their sports team, for example), and that younger students were not as highly represented percentage wise in the more advanced high school classes, but experts are warning that while the numbers may appear conclusive, there’s still no evidence that redshirting your child will reap the positive long terms results parents are hoping for. 

So my question today is to get your view on the debate. Would you redshirt your child to give them an advantage on what some claim, is a life advantage that carries far past kindergarten? Have you redshirted your child? Did you opt out like I did? Are you on the fence? I’d love your side on this debate. 

Erica3

37 Comments
  1. I did not red shirt and didn’t consider it. Yet, I feel both my kids have been impacted by others red shirting their kids. Take my son. His birthday is in July while the cut-off date is December. I never thought of holding him back being born in the middle of the Dec-Nov school year range, but he is often the youngest in his class now. That’s right. Everyone else held their July-November babies back. He is in middle school now and plays sports and I see where the bigger kids in the lower grades, vs. my big kid in his current grade, have an edge on teams.

    Meanwhile my daughter was a December baby. So she should have been the oldest as the cutoff is Dec 1. Yet here we go again with everyone holding back their July-Nov babies! I swear half her class celebrates being a year older before she gets to in December. It’s all so weird to me.

  2. I always thought I would not hold my kid back. One of my many “before I became a parent” holier than thou hangups, I guess.

    But after one full year of Montessori preK, my son’s teachers and my husband and I agreed he was not ready for kindergarten this year (even though he turned 5 over the summer and technically could have been a kindergartner).

    What I LOVE is how his teachers call it “gifting him another year” rather than holding back, redshirting or other less positive terms. They said it is simply giving him the time and space he needs to develop the necessary skills and maturity to be a successful learner.

    As you can tell, I am head over heels with his teachers and our wonderful Montessori school as a whole 🙂 It works for us.

  3. I see this from another perspective; I am a teacher. When friends ask me about redshirting kindergarten or pushing a young child ahead, I don’t talk about kindergarten. I ask them, “Will your child be ready for first grade next year?” If the child isn’t mature enough to demonstrate basic book sense or count math manipulative materials, redshirting might be a good idea. If the child is academically and socially ready, by all means enroll him/her in school. Don’t hold back for a later physical advantage that might not even be important to the child.

  4. My daughter has an August bday, so we are trying to make this decision now. I’ve consulted many sources, and some parents and teachers have told me they have concerns when these “redshirted” kids are older. Most will be 18 for the entire senior year, and it certainly becomes apparent during the puberty years. I guess you need to really look at your kid and make the call. Are you doing it because your child isn’t ready? Or are you doing it because you’re trying to give them an upper hand advantage? My oldest has a summer birthday and he is fine academically, socially, etc. Some of his classmates, however, are larger and starting to hit puberty. They are getting interested in girls, and my kid just isn’t there since he is a whole year younger. I guess I’m in the camp that those kids who meet the cut off should go, unless they just can’t handle it socially.

  5. So if you are interested in increasing the revenue of your online
    business, you must take the help of an SEO agency in Singapore.
    What if that site got to where it’s at because you hired an SEO company and they were SO smart that they had figured out Google’s algorithm and gotten you the spots you paid them to get you
    strategically. Whether you know it or not, there are a lot of
    different channels that you can explore to get more market share, but that
    doesn’t come without a little bit of work.

  6. you are in reality a just right webmaster. The site
    loading speed is incredible. It sort of feels that you’re doing any unique trick.
    Furthermore, The contents are masterpiece. you
    have done a excellent task in this topic!

  7. Whenever a developer faces a styling problem, he can quickly
    turn on the Hierarchy Viewer. Every developer realizes the fact that nothing can replace a well-equipped system (like a desktop, or a system
    in workplace) for accomplishing their tasks. Even the military uses them to send and
    receive top secret information.

  8. I’m not certain where you’re getting your info, but great topic.
    I needs to spend some time learning much more or working out more.
    Thank you for magnificent info I used to be in search of this info
    for my mission.

  9. Your PPC effort gain from their years of encounter dealing with countless projects in numerous various sectors.
    If you are visiting utilize ppc management services, Nichole,
    see to it that the agency also offers SEO, since their know-how and also data
    from seo could be made use of to assist develop a
    much more effective Pay Per Click strategy. It likewise permits you to expand your digital marketing by including search engine optimization to really ramp up your advertising and marketing.

  10. you’re in reality a excellent webmaster. The site loading speed is amazing.
    It sort of feels that you’re doing any distinctive trick.
    Also, The contents are masterpiece. you’ve done a excellent job
    in this subject!

  11. If you want to fill the entire monitor, (perhaps for a Powerpoint presentation) the commonest monitor size today is 1024 x
    600 pixels, which is still only 0. This is the site where you want visitors to
    purchase products or services, join business opportunities, and the like.
    It takes many years of daily training and study
    to achieve these skills just like as it takes many years to become a good attorney, or doctor or any other specialist in a field.

  12. I’m not sure where you’re getting your info, but good topic.

    I needs to spend some time learning much more or understanding more.
    Thanks for excellent info I was looking for this info for my mission.

  13. I’m impressed, I have to admit. Rarely do I come across a
    blog that’s both educative and entertaining, and let me tell
    you, you’ve hit the nail on the head. The problem is something which too few men and women are
    speaking intelligently about. Now i’m very
    happy that I stumbled across this in my hunt for something regarding
    this.

  14. Wonderful goods from you, man. I’ve understand your stuff previous to and you’re just extremely wonderful.
    I actually like what you have acquired here, really
    like what you are stating and the way in which you say it.

    You make it entertaining and you still take care of to keep it wise.

    I can not wait to read much more from you. This is really a terrific site.

  15. Hey there I am so thrilled I found your weblog, I really found you by error, while I was looking
    on Aol for something else, Nonetheless I am here now and would
    just like to say thanks for a fantastic post and a all round interesting blog (I
    also love the theme/design), I don’t have time to browse it all at the
    moment but I have saved it and also added your RSS feeds,
    so when I have time I will be back to read much more,
    Please do keep up the great jo.

  16. I have learn several excellent stuff here. Certainly price bookmarking for revisiting.
    I surprise how much attempt you place to create one
    of these fantastic informative web site.

  17. Thanks for the marvelous posting! I truly enjoyed reading it, you will be a great
    author. I will be sure to bookmark your blog and will often come back
    from now on. I want to encourage you to ultimately continue your great work, have a
    nice morning!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.